Harley Benton PB-Shorty BK Standard Series

Only being an amatuer bassist I wanted a cheap short scale instrument to add to my arsenal.
I am not disapointed, great finish, great sound and great value.
I have already upgraded the strings to the GHS Stainless flatwounds, polished the frets, cleaned and oiled the fretboard, set the intonation to a higher standard than when it came out of the box, made a custom Ash wood pickguard and created a bone nut. I have just orderd some more parts for further upgrades as follows: Gotoh GB10 4L N Bass Tuners - Göldo HW50C 3-D Bass Bridge, both items have been ordered from Thomann. Now you know that I have further improvement plans for this instrument let me tell you why I spent the extra on these parts. When I first recieved this instrument the frets needed zero attention, I polished them because I changed the strings and I could. The pickguard was made purely for aesethetics and to add my own customization. The bone nut in my opinion was a "needed" upgrade because the nut that came fitted was some cheap soft plastic and probably reduced the sustain.
The strings HAD to be replaced because a: I prefer flatwound for the sound and my amateur fingers take less abuse, b: The original strings were terrible! The intonation wasn't actually that bad, I suspect that storage time and temperature change had an effect on the original setup. Which leads me to why I oiled the fretboard, storage time had dried it up somewhat and so a little fretboard oil was needed. Now I have spent some time playing and enjoying a great value for money instrument I feel it's time to add some further upgrades to enjoy it even more. Two of the machine heads (tuners) can be turned by nearly half a revoloution before they actually tighten or loosen the strings, on closer inspection I can see that the shaft of the keys are loose in the mechanism, now I could perhaps bend the whole tuner (machine head) plate to tighten on the shaft and stop the loose action of the tuning key but I'd rather replace them with some top quality tuners and enjoy reliable tuning action. The bridge replacement is mainly because I want a higher mass bridge to hopefully achieve more sustain and to be honest I want a more contemporary look, it isn't in my opinion a necessary upgrade but one I want to achieve a more unique Harley Benton Shorty custom.
I ain't no expert, I can setup a guitar and a bass and I can be honest, if you want my opinion this instrument is a NO BRAINER if you are looking for a short scale bass and for what ever your reasons don't want to spend an arm and a leg you, cannot go wrog with this instrument. Out of the box it will serve anyone and if you want it to serve you better or more it is easily upgradeable and easily worth spending a few quid at the local luthier to get it to perform at a satisfying level.
Next upgrade for me will be either a Tone Rider Pick up or a Wilkinson pick up, both Alnico V but to be honest the ceramic pick up that comes fitted is actually surprisingly good, nice warm sound with the GHS flatwounds I have fitted that punch if you dig in, again it's me being a tart and wanting to customise rather than a necessary upgrade. I hope that if you go for one of these you enjoy the same or similar experience as me!
A good one!

Unboxing Harley Benton PB Shorty was really a nice surprise. I have to say that I did not expect too much for the price I paid for this one. My feedback is based on the quality of this bass considering the very low price. After a few months of playing it I am very sure that this bass is the best bass in the market for the price. This one also beats all of the basses I have tried in local music stores that cost up to 10 times as much as this one.

My first impression was the looks of it as I unboxed it. It looked just fantastic and the finish was perfect. This bass is very light and is really easy to handle. Setup, intonation, playablility and feel was great right out of the box so I just had to tune it.
After playing for a short while I noticed that the fret ends kind of cut the skin on my left thumb. This was no big deal. It took no more than 5 minutes to file the sharp fret ends and after that it has been a dream to play. I give 4 quality stars because of the sharp fret ends.
I also have to add that the neck has got a kind of satin feel to it, something I prefer over a gloss neck since they tend to feel kind of sticky. This is my first short scale bass and as a guitar player I find this a lot easier to play than basses with longer scale.

After plugging the bass in I was sure that this was a good deal. It is quite easy to find the different tones with this one. I use this bass in the studio and have played it clean and with lots of different effects. It sounds a bit thin and weak played clean, and that is the only reason it get 4 stars for the sound. The machine heads is doing a good job and this bass stays in tune. I also want to add that this bass is usually perfectly in tune even if I have not played it for a few days.

Pros:
Fantastic value for money
Perfect finish
Stays in tune
Great playability
Good sound
All in all a great product

Cons:
Sharp fret ends on the "thumb side" of the neck.
A better patent for picup height adjustment. I would prefer a better solution than the kind of foam block under the pickups. It hardens and then it becomes an issue to adjust the height.

To wrap up my opinions on the Harley Benton PB shorty I have to say that you really can't go wrong with this one. I will say that this bass is perfect for the beginner (even if you have to pay someone for a setup), but I will also recommend this for more experienced players. This is really a great instrument.

Having read the reviews I was expecting the possibility of problems / issues. So it was with some trepidation that I opened the box. I can say I was utterly, utterly surprised. So lets start with the aesthetics.

Fit and finish:
It's flawless. I really have tried to find something negative to report but there isn't anything at all. The neck is beautiful, quality, one piece construction with a deep rosewood fretboard. Frets are superbly finished, there isn't one sharp edge, anywhere.

The body:
Poplar? Feels nice, not heavy, solid and resonant. The paintwork - it's a joy, it's perfect. It has a 3 layer laminated scratchplate. The finish and feel of the volume and tone is excellent. The bridge and machine heads - all perfectly aligned, good quality, feel solid.

Setup:
I expected to need to do 'something', I have never had a guitar that was good to go out of the box. I even thought I would be tied up for hours fiddling and changing settings. Not a bit of it! The neck is set perfectly, the string height is spot on, the intonation if dead on. All I had to was tune it.

Sound:
I am using a Pocket Pod. To say I am happy with the pickups is an understatement. With my Line 6, anything can sound like anything and there were and are no issues with pickups, volume or tone.

Playability:
Well, it's exercising my short stubby fingers which is a bonus but, I can reach and play what I want which is always difficulty for me with a guitar with a long neck. Short scale does not mean short on sound or depth. And the feel and finish of the neck is just a dream. I spent the night tuned for Jason Newstead Cunning Stunts solo with a big, silly, grin on my face.

Sometimes cut price means dubious quality. I honestly have no idea how something so so good can be for sale for so so little. Bonkers, and I got a long guitar lead thrown in. How can that not be the bargain of the century. For the price of a labelled gig bag I got a beautiful bass guitar and I have nothing but praise for Thomann and their own brand kit. - Wow.

Timely update:
You know how it is as time passes and the new toy gloss wears off. Yep, it happened. I have to admit with some music (if you can call what I do music) when using my Pod, I am struggling a bit to get anything like a decent output from the bass for certain genres of music.

I really just couldn't get it up there and the reviews I was reading said - CHANGE THE STRINGS. The advice was that the ones that are fitted set are poor quality, they have low output. I was being told to spend some money, spend more money, change the strings.

But, I am from Yorkshire, we as a breed have very short arms and VERY deep pockets. So, I decided to have a look instead of ringing Thomann. Hmm. The pickup output was spot on at 8.56 so there had to be another reason. Logic kept saying, I shouldn't believe it could be the strings that's bonkers.

Come on, think about it, they are just steel wire vibrating in a magnetic field. So. It if was 'just the strings' playing them harder would have some effect wouldn't it? But it didn't, well, not enough to notice. I needed a longer ponder and then I pulled the pickups. It was an 'argh' moment. The foam rubber P. Bass pickup support blocks had compressed, they were clearly setting the pickups way too low. Well, way too low (for me). So, I re-set the screws, gave the covers a pull and bingo - ROARING. No, before you state something like buzz, crack and sustain, they are not too close to the strings, in fact they are perfect, just like my Les Paul. I'm ripping it.

So:
SANITY WARNING. DO NOT BELIEVE EVERYTHING YOU READ ON THE WEB. DO NOT WASTE YOUR MONEY, THINK FIRST. THINK BEFORE SPENDING ON NEW KIT OR NEW STRINGS. iF YOUR OUTPUT IS LOW START AT THE BOTTOM - loosen the pickups, lift them, set them, until they hit their sweet spot.

Dear Mr Thomann. Please, do you sell additional / replacement foam blocks or do I have to nip down to my local hardware store for some draft strip. Thanks.

I play in a ukulele band and have been using a Ubass. I decided it was time to go the whole hog and switch to a 'proper' bass.
I tried unsuccessfully to play a full size instrument but being used to the Ubass's short scale it was too much of a jump for me. A friend suggested a short scale bass, so not wanting to waste money I googled cheapest bass guitar.
It arrived a week ago. I have to say the quality of the instrument is amazing, apart from tuning it played straight out of the box.
I've made a couple of changes, I fitted a bone nut and changed the strings to flatwound (my poor amateur fingers suffered with the roundwounds) A slight tweek of the truss rod to lower the action and I also adjusted the intonation.
I'm gigging with it on Friday and believe it or not I'm looking forward to showing off my £75 bass!

It arrived needing a little set up and the strings are kind of pants but that's all an easy fix even for a beginner. I put some flatwounds on and it feels great to play.
Neck feels good, no fret sprouting and nice and straight out of the box.
The pickups aren't great to be honest, they're not the worst i've heard but they're going to be the first thing i upgrade, plenty of thump to get started though. There is a buzzing sound when you aren't touching the strings but i suspect that some copper tape or something lining the cavity would help greatly, again a nice easy job for a beginner.
Even though i wouldn't rate the performance of the bass very highly i'm giving this a 5 star because the price is just so damn accessible, such a low cost of entry to start playing bass or, if you're like me, to experiment with shortscale.

UPDATE: I have lined the cavity and the underside of the scratchplate with copper tape and the hum has totally gone, it might be all in my head but the pickups sound better too. Fun little bass!

For the very small price it is worth 5 stars. It was playable out of the box, but I adjusted the truss rod and bridge saddles to lower the action to suit my style, and I also adjusted the intonation. I didn't like the strings that were on the guitar (very quiet and floppy) and changed them for stainless steel flatwounds straight away. Now the little monster sounds great - just like a PB to my ears. At this price everyone should have one, if only to explore the possibilities.
Update -Jan 2016
Since my last comments I have experimented with different strings. The original strings are almost useless - no volume or thump and are best discarded. The issue then, as with most short scale basses is finding strings (in my case the only problem is the low "E") that fit properly i.e. they fit correctly between the nut and the bridge saddle without the silk windings or the fattest part of the taper being inside the "speaking length". The smallest strings made by some of the manufactures are far too long at 34". Other manufacturers give a speaking length of 32", which is still around 20mm too long for this bass. I used a spacer and washer at the ball end of the E string to get GHS Flatwound Precision Bass 3020 strings to fit. Expensive but very nice sound with a good thump, but after a while I became fed up of the 20mm sticking out of the end of the bridge. I unwound the wires from the ball, shortened the length then re-wound but I lost the winding tension and spoiled the string. It fitted but didn't sound great. Next I tried Fender Nickel 5250XL roundwound strings. Same issue of excess length with the E string - this time I carefully soldered a brass collar on the string , then cut it 20mm shorter at the ball end - success this time. They sounded very good and bright with super piano tones, especially when new. They don't feel very stiff though, which may be to some tastes. Also they are quite noisy/ clacky but that is probably my fault. These are good strings at a moderate price.
Next up - back to stainless flatwounds - Daddorio ECB81S chromes at an unbeatable price from Thomann. These strings fit without any alterations. They are pretty stiff, which I like a lot, especially when digging in a bit. I find I can get different volumes with these strings depending on how hard I play, which I didn't notice with the others. They look very well made - better than the GHS I think. The sound is really excellent - very thumpy and deep and of course there is no finger noise. The bass feels and plays really good now.
I bought some spare Harley Benton P-bass nuts from Thomann as all these string sets differ slightly in thickness and minor filing may be required to get the best fit . At the low price it takes the worry away of spoiling the nut. The original nut is quite soft and can break when disturbed.
Great Bass - even better with great strings.

I have bought many HB guitars and this one is my 2nd HB Bass. The first one was a JB-75NA and was a great bass out of the box. This Shorty is the same! Nothing to complain here and for the price its just amazing!

Fretwork is perfect! Polished and crowned AND rounded frets! 79 Euros!
The Roseacer fretbaord looks more like Ebony to me than the rather ugly Roseacer one get on the CST or SC model HB guitars! Very happy with this bass!

The stock strings were wrapped into oily paper to keep them fresh and shiny. Stock strings sound very punchy and will not change them any time soon.

Tuners works as they should. Body paint and satin neck finish are perfect.
Im yet to open the pickguard and look under the hood. I do get slight buzz when I take my hands off the strings so some shielding will be needed Im guessing.

All in all, fantastic buy and surely suits me well as my main instrument is a guitar (Shorty) !

One of my sons has shown an interest in playing bass so had a hunt about for a short scale (he's10) and ordered the Harley Benton Shorty from Thomann.

It's £85 so wasn't sure what to expect but the reviews are actually pretty favourable.

Out the box it needed tuning but was actually pretty playable, in fact it would have done a beginner as is. Light and easy to hold, not too much neck dive, neck is satin finish, smooth and feels really good, no sharp fret ends but frets dull and needed polishing. Tuners seem good, finish looks good, bridge is a Harley Benton own brand, nut it the most plastic looking nut I've ever seen.

Truss rod relief was ~0.2mm, action slightly high, pickups way too low, nut slightly high ~0.15.

After setting up truss relief to 0.3mm, action 2 - 2.4mm and dialed in the intonation, it was already playing better. Pickups were at the max and still way too low.

Removed the old strings.

Added packers under the pickups to give the extra height, polished the frets, cleaned and oiled the dryish fingerboard, restrung with D'Addario EXL220S.

Now plays even better and could even have the action lowered slightly I think.

Upgrades would be the nut and pickups but not for a while, worth considering if you're after a short scale as it's the best value for the price out there, even better if you can tweak it yourself with a basic setup.

In fact, think I'll just keep it myself......

I was looking for a affordable way to get into bass guitar, because I've been having the urge to play some bass lines.

I'm actually a guitarist, and a while back I got a second hand CST24 Harley Benton and was actually suprised to see a decent instrument (apart from some finishing details) for such a low price.

After reading some reviews I decided, since it was just for testing whether bass guitar is a thing for me, to get the Harley Benton PB-Shorty. Honestly, because that was the cheapest option.

Once I got it, I was godsmacked about the quality considering the amount of money it costs. Good fretwork, no sprouting. Tuners are well aligned and no finishing flaws. All I had to do was tune it.

If I compare the craftmanship to my Fender MIM Stratocaster, bought in 1997, it is a day and night difference. That one had the worse routing job ever, a bad nut and sharp frets. Compared to that abomination, this Harley Benton is emmaculate.

Very well done Thomann! This enables making music affordable to anyone.

Cheers!